The Summer House Season 9 reunion trailer just dropped (May 21), and it's safe to say the Hamptons heat is carrying over into the Bravo Clubhouse. 

Set on what looks like a massive, pastel bed, the trailer reunites Paige DeSorbo, Lindsay Hubbard, Amanda Batula, Kyle Cooke, West Wilson, Lexi Wood, Carl Radke, Jesse Solomon, Ciara Miller, Gabby Prescod, and Imrul Hassan. Judging by the short but spicy teaser, no one is safe from the hot seat.

While Andy Cohen is clearly ready to get answers, fans have already gone into full-blown theory mode – decoding looks, reactions, and one-liners. 

Here's a breakdown of the biggest fan theories circulating ahead of the reunion's premiere.

1. The OG Girls Are Graduating to RHONY or Getting Their Own Spinoff

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by @amandabatula

Fans suspect Bravo may be prepping something bigger for Paige, Amanda, Lindsay, and Ciara. Whether it's a Next Gen NYC transition, becoming new cast members of The Real Housewives of New York, or a Hamptons-based spinoff, the original girl gang has enough power, influence, and drama to carry their own show. 

2. Amanda Might Share Baby Plans (Or Something Close)

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by @amandabatula

Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke have long teased the idea of starting a family, and with their relationship in a more stable place this season, fans think Amanda may reveal an update – not necessarily a pregnancy, but alternative options such as egg freezing or long-term planning. All eyes will be on her when the topic of their future comes up.

3. Paige Will Spill the Real Tea on Craig

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by PAIGE DESORBO (@paige_desorbo)

Paige's on-again, off-again relationship with Southern Charm's Craig Conover hit a boiling point this season. The reality star hinted at insecurities brewing behind the scenes, with fans speculating Craig felt threatened by Paige's fame and independence. Expect a more unfiltered Paige and possibly some never-before-heard details on what finally broke them.

4. Lindsay Will Pretend to Be Private About Her Love Life (Again)

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Bravo (@bravotv)

Classic Lindsay Hubbard – giving just enough to spark curiosity but not enough to satisfy it. While fans expect her to address life post-Carl and post-engagement, many predict she'll deflect by saying she wants to "keep it private." Many Bravoholics also believe she will go into detail about her boyfriend, Turner Kufe, and whether or not they have had relationship issues since welcoming their daughter. 

5. Carl Will Talk About His Bar… Which Still Isn't Open

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Soft Bar + Cafe (@softbarcafe)

Carl Radke's passion project, SoftBar, will definitely be a reunion topic. The problem? Fans are already dragging him for his lack of progress. Don't be surprised if Andy questions him about the status and Carl gives a vague answer with a buzzword or two – "in the works," "soon," or "community-focused." 

6. Ciara's Ready to Go Off on Jesse and West

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Jesse Solomon (@jessesols)

Ciara Miller has had it with the boys, and fans are betting she's about to make that crystal clear. From Jesse's messy antics to West's flirty but non-committal behavior, viewers believe Ciara will confront both men at the reunion and possibly deliver the night's most viral clapback.

7. Lexi Gives Jesse the Reality Check He Deserves

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by lexi wood👼🏼 (@lexiwood)

Lexi Wood came into the house wanting a real relationship, and Jesse Solomon made sure to ruin that dream at every turn. Fans predict Lexi will not hold back at the reunion, serving a brutally honest takedown that will leave Jesse speechless or at least sweating through his pastel suit. 

8. The Women Will (Shockingly) Side with Jesse

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Jesse Solomon (@jessesols)

Despite his questionable behavior, there's a growing theory that the other girls – perhaps out of loyalty or group dynamics – will take Jesse's side over Lexi's. If true, that alliance will definitely cause tension, especially with Lexi, who never shied away from calling out hypocrisy in the house.

The Summer House reunion kicks off on Wednesday (May 28) at 9 p.m. ET/PT. The second part of the reunion will air on Wednesday, June 4, at 9 p.m. ET/PT. 

Photo Credit: @bravotv on Instagram.